Opened in June 2017, Isola means island in Italian.   Isola represents the marriage of modern Italian cuisine and seasonal dishes featuring the freshest ingredients the East End has to offer, giving guests a true taste of Shelter Island living, with a Mediterranean flair.

Isola’s wine list presents the best of Long Island’s wine country, accompanied by our favorite European vintages.  The cocktail menu is curated to complement not only our cuisine, but Shelter Island’s relaxed and inspiring atmosphere.

Our 140 seat restaurant features indoor and outdoor seating, a traditional bar, and open air pizza kitchen overlooking the dining room.  Guests may choose to dine in the lively main dining room, spacious bar, side patio, or street front on our scenic front porch overlooking the Historic Shelter Island Heights District.

Isola is owned by Italian food and Shelter Island lover, Brad Kitkowski.

isolany restaurant shelter island ny chef seth nathan

Seth Nathan

Executive Chef

chef seth nathan isola restaurant shelter island new york



Fri/Sat            5:00pm to 10:00pm

Sun                 5:00pm to 9:00pm

Mon                Closed

Tues – Thurs  5:00pm to 9:00pm

Reservations & Inquiries

Isola accepts reservations a month prior to your dining date.

Press inquiries: brad@isolany.com


15 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

15 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

Get Directions

Weekly Specials

Sunday – Spaghetti and Meatball night – two meatballs and side salad – $15

Tuesday – Two for one Pizza night – buy one Pizza and get the same or less value Pizza for free

Weds – Isola’s Famous Chicken Parm $18

Thursday – Rib Eye Steak night with side salad – $25

Winter Menu 2018


Feeling Frisky?

Danielle Hamptons

Envy Worthy Dining on New York’s Shelter Island


Mangiare Per Vivere: Isola Restaurant Opens On Shelter Island

The Independent

Isola on Shelter Island
Isola on Shelter Island

East End Taste

Isola settles in for the long run
Isola settles in for the long run

Shelter Island Reporter

Chefs Dish on What to Eat on Shelter Island This Summer


Chef Nathan isola restaurant shelter island
Chef named for Isola — Shelter Island’s newest restaurant

Shelter Island by Northforker

Isola on Instagram

Instagram has returned invalid data.